Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Broken Arrow, OK

We wanted to try it for quite a few weeks and ended up going 2 days in a row. Great customer service, amazing prices, and great pizza. Crispy and pipping hot crust, made these pizzas amazing. We had the Manhattan Meat & the New York cheese, a slice of the State Island White, a classic cannoli, 2 Ghiradelli chocolate cheese cake, plain and a cherry New York cheese cakes on our 1st visit. The next day, we had a New York cheese and a Bronx Chicken Alfredo to go. Both times, the service was on point, the quality and flavor were amazing, and the prices were extremely reasonable. We are definitely returning to try more menu items, especially the Cheesecake Calzone

I got the Staten Island White, Bronx Chicken Alfredo, cheese garlic knots. Slices were huge and cooked perfectly. Probably one of my new favorite pizza joints. The knots aren't bad, but I could live without them. Service was great, check it out yourself.

Absolutely love coming here. The food is great, perfect crust. Good desserts. Fun staff. I drive from out of town to come here and will continue.

Whether or not it is “New York” style or not is irrelevant to me. I ain’t much of a pizza critic. A Pizza Hut sausage on thin crust with a cold beer, works for me! But today, my wife and I were looking for a white pizza. That search brought us to the new Broken Arrow, Jimmy’s New York Pizza for a pan of Staten Island White. It was and excellent example of crust covered with Garlic Oil Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Ricotta Cheese & Minced Garlic. It was enjoyable, but not quite what I was looking for in a white pizza. I think Bronx Chicken Alfredo will be closer to matching the memory I have of one I enjoyed many years ago. The restaurant is spacious. Windows all around. Clean with good friendly service.

Came here around the holidays based on a few reviews we had read. We drove almost an hour, and they were closed. Their phone and internet weren't updated. We drove up again today, and being from NY I know I have high expectations, but this place was pure disappointment. It was empty but we were in between lunch I guess (1:05pm). We ordered a Margherita pizza and another regular meat mixed kind. The Marg had a decent crust but SOOOOOOO soggy for 3/4 of it. The red sauce had ZERO flavor. ea. slice had a large leaf of basil, looked nice - impossible to bite through. A blob of cheese as well, which was just strange. I actually sprinkled a bit of salt on it to bring out some sort of flavor. I generally eat very LOW sodium and NEVER add salt. This would speak volumes if you knew/know me. My husband's pizza tasted much better but WHOA the grease dripping off it was horrendous. So, still on the hunt for a pie that will make me happy. This was $50 of no happy !!! We saw a couple by CVS with a hungry sign, so we gave them the pizzas -

My husband and I drove from Yukon Ok to eat here. We love it here but today was awful. The kid working behind the counter had no personality and was very short with us. When I asked to make sure he had notes I did t want any garlic in my calzone I was politely told to look at my receipt. I asked if there were more Cokes in the back because their drink fountain was broken he said in a snarky tone what I have is the cooler. There wasn’t much in the cooler. I get my calzone and low and behold what was in my calzone but garlic. This kid wanted to argue when he was bringing out my calzone. The cook in the back was cussing about me asking for pizza sauce. This is the worst experience we have ever had here and we are so shocked!!! It’s a shame because Jimmy's has excellent food!! Not sure when or if we will be back. We could hear the cook and the kid taking crap about it’s in the kitchen. This is not the experience we are used to here!!

First time here, not busy, actually sadly empty. Perhaps they do more to go orders? Clean and nice atmosphere. I was hoping for yummy crispy NY pizza. It fell a bit short. It was good but lacked in flavor. Next time I would hit my to go slices with a bit of garlic. It's a bit pricey in my opinion but food prices are higher.

They have a great pie...the wife had a veggie and I pepperoni....I thought by the way people were eating this pizza by folding it over....it was going to be tuff like a lot of the NY pizzas are but I was pleased to see that this wasn't the case the foundation (crust) was thin but tender and crunchy. The toppings were good and the wife also could not find falt with her pie.....however, pizza is everywhere...that the great thing about pizza...it's all different but good...but, we both thought for what you ended up getting was good just ridiculously over priced.