Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow Menu
Welcome to Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow, a slice of New York right in Oklahoma! Located at 3312 S Elm Pl, this vibrant eatery serves up an impressive array of pizzas, pastas, and desserts that leave a lasting impression. Customers rave about the crispy, piping hot crust of their pies, with the Manhattan Meat and classic New York cheese stealing the spotlight.
- Must-Try Pizzas: Staten Island White and Bronx Chicken Alfredo are favorites.
- Delectable Desserts: Indulge in creamy cheesecakes and delightful cannoli.
- Top-Notch Service: Friendly staff enhances the dining experience.
Despite some mixed reviews, many patrons are eager to return, drawn by the affordable prices and rich flavors. Jimmy's New York Pizzeria promises an entertaining culinary journey that’s worth exploring!
Hot Pasta
Manicotti
Pasta tubes stuffed with seasoned ricotta and cheese, topped with Jimmy's New York cheese blend and marinara sauce.
Spaghetti & Italian Sausage
Spaghetti topped with Jimmy's famous Italian sausage and marinara sauce.
Lasagna
Layered with meat, cheese and marinara sauce.
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Spaghetti topped with Jimmy's famous meatballs and marinara sauce.
Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken & Bacon
Fettuccine pasta, with garlic chicken and bacon topped with alfredo sauce.
New York Cheese
Jimmy's famous pizza sauce and New York premium cheese blend.
Liberty Supreme
Pepperoni, meatball, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms and black olives.
East Coast Veggie
Spinach, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, fresh tomatoes.
Classic Pies
New York Appetizers
Extra Ranch, Marinara Or Alfredo
Extra Garlic Knot
Garlic Knots (3)
Prepared with fresh garlic oil, baked to golden brown and sprinkled with Jimmy's special blend of spices (served with side of marinara sauce).
Cheese Knots (3)
Garlic knots topped with Jimmy's New York premium mozzarella cheese blend (served with side of marinara sauce).
Insalata Caprese
Sliced fresh all natural mozzarella, sliced tomatoes topped with fresh basil, olive oil, black pepper and Himalayan salt.
Capri Sun
Keep the kids happy.
Pellegrino
Go ahead and upgrade your water to an Italian sparkling water.
Fountain Drink (Jimmy's Souvenir 22oz Cup)
Coca-Cola Classic, Diet Coca-Cola, Root Beer, Sprite, Lemonade and Dr. Pepper.
2 Liter Soda
Availability varies.
Bottled Beverages
Availability varies.
Bottled Water
Drinks
Salads
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, fresh shredded parmesan, pecorino Romano and seasoned croutons.
Greek Feta
Romaine lettuce, spring mix, cherry tomatoes, red onions, black olives, feta cheese and seasoned croutons.
House Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, spring mix, cherry tomatoes, red onions, shredded carrots and seasoned croutons.
Cannoli
Italian pastry shell filled with a creamy sweet filling and sprinkled with powdered sugar. Choose from: classic or chocolate dipped shell.
New York Cheesecake
Served by the slice. Choose from: plain, cherry topping or Ghirardelli chocolate topping.
Cheesecake Calzone
Yes, you did read that correctly. Jimmy's pastry dough filled with creamy New York cheesecake, spices and baked to perfection. You have to try it!
Mini Cannoli (Classic Shell)
Desserts
Hot Hero Sandwiches
Italian Combo
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, drizzled with olive oil, vinegar, salt and pepper.
Prosciutto & Provolone
Thinly sliced prosciutto (Italian ham), provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, drizzled with olive oil and vinegar, salt and pepper.
Ham & Mozzarella
Ham, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, drizzled with olive oil, vinegar, salt and pepper.
Meatball Parmesan
Homemade meatballs covered in Jimmy's marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, sprinkled with fresh parmesan cheese.
Calzone
Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough filled with fresh mozzarella cheese, garlic and ricotta, folded, baked and served with a side of marinara sauce.
Stromboli
Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough filled with Genoa salami, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mozzarella, folded, baked and served with a side marinara sauce.
Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese and garlic rolled and baked in Jimmy's famous hand tossed dough.
Jimmys Specialties
Five Boroughs Pizza Pies
Staten Island White
Garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, sliced tomatoes, fresh ricotta cheese and minced garlic.
Queen's Margherita
Italian plum tomato sauce, fresh all natural mozzarella cheese, pecorino cheese, garlic oil, Himalayan salt, black pepper, and fresh basil.
Bronx Chicken Alfredo Pie
Garlic alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh chicken and bacon.
Brooklyn Prosciutto
Garlic oil sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh asiago cheese, thinly sliced prosciutto (italian ham), cherry tomatoes, and fresh basil.
Manhattan Meat
Fresh mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, meatball, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage and bacon.
12" Manhattan Meat Slice
Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage, bacon, and meatball.
12" Staten Island White Slice
Garlic oil sauce, sliced tomatoes, fresh ricotta cheese and minced garlic.
12" Liberty Supreme Slice
Pepperoni, meatballs, red onions, green peppers, black olives, and mushrooms.
12" New York Cheese Slice
Jimmy's famous pizza sauce and New York premium cheese blend.
12" East Coast Veggie Slice
Spinach, red onions, green peppers, mushroom, black olives and fresh tomatoes.
12" Bronx Chicken Alfredo Slice
Garlic alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh chicken and bacon.
By the Slice
Special Diet
Keto Bowl
Fresh mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, meat balls, fresh chicken, black olives, minced garlic, and pizza sauce.
Gluten Free / Cauliflower Pizza - Cheese Only
Gluten free. 10" pizza with your choice of gluten free toppings for a fee each. Gluten free toppings: bacon, chicken, spinach, green peppers, red onions, jalapeños, mushrooms, black olives, fresh tomatoes, anchovies, feta cheese, garlic and ricotta.
6" 1 Topping Kids New York Pizza & Kids Drink
6" New York-style pizza with choice of one topping from an assortment including meats, vegetables, or extra cheese. Served with Capri Sun.
Fettuccine Alfredo W/ Chicken & Bacon & Kids Drink
Fettuccine pasta, with garlic chicken and bacon topped with alfredo sauce.